Community First Credit Union
Appleton, WI · EIN 39-6264347 · Rank 1,855 by total revenue
Our mission is to be our members' primary financial services provider
Money, Form 990 for tax year 2025
- Total revenue
- $353,663,620
- Total expenses
- $272,137,434
- Total assets
- $6,370,358,954
- Salary base (all salaries and wages)
- $45,239,439
- Salaries, other pay and benefits
- $56,670,332
- Employees
- 712
- Salary base per employee
- $63,539
"Salary base" is Form 990 Part IX lines 5 to 7. "Employees" is everyone who got a W-2 that year, full or part time. Form 990-EZ and 990-PF report pay differently; see About the data.
Leadership (21)
| Name | Title | Role | Hours/week | Total pay |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Catherine Tierney | CEO/PRESIDENT / BOD - TREASURER | Board, Officer | 40 | $1,679,002 |
| Scott Steinfort | CHIEF TECHNOLOGY OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $562,944 |
| Charles Bostick | CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $562,430 |
| Amanda Secor | CHIEF OF STAFF | Officer | 40 | $508,964 |
| Karrie Drobnick | CHIEF STRATEGY AND EXPERIENCE OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $436,134 |
| Kristy Hesse | CHIEF HR OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $431,594 |
| Timothy Hoff | CHIEF LENDING OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $329,962 |
| Shawn Mulhaney | CHIEF MEMBER SERVICE OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $255,548 |
| Jennifer Diloreto | CHIEF RISK OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $144,323 |
| Carrie O'Connor | CHIEF LENDING OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $104,554 |
| Michael Moore | VICE CHAIRPERSON | Board, Officer | 1 | None reported |
| Peter Mariahazy | CHAIRPERSON | Board, Officer | 1 | None reported |
| Matthew Bingham | SECRETARY | Board, Officer | 1 | None reported |
| Kathryn Sieman | BOARD MEMBER | Board | 1 | None reported |
| Sara Micheletti | BOARD MEMBER | Board | 1 | None reported |
| Jay Fulkerson | BOARD MEMBER - EMERITUS | Board | 1 | None reported |
| Daniel Ferris | BOARD MEMBER | Board | 1 | None reported |
| Paul Schwartz | BOARD MEMBER | Board | 1 | None reported |
| Amy Fricke-Weigel | BOARD MEMBER | Board | 1 | None reported |
| Adam Swoverland | BOARD MEMBER | Board | 1 | None reported |
| Sarah Hutchinson | BOARD MEMBER | Board | 1 | None reported |
Top 10 paid people listed
These 10 people received $6,123,140, which is 13.5% of the $45,239,439 salary base shared by 712 employees.
| Name | Title | Role | Hours/week | From this org | From related orgs | Other pay | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Catherine Tierney | CEO/PRESIDENT / BOD - TREASURER | Board, Officer | 40 | $1,652,164 | $0 | $26,838 | $1,679,002 |
| Jeffrey Garrett | CFFA PROGRAM MANAGER | Highly paid employee | 40 | $556,784 | $0 | $88,005 | $644,789 |
| Scott Steinfort | CHIEF TECHNOLOGY OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $482,057 | $0 | $80,887 | $562,944 |
| Charles Bostick | CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $538,411 | $0 | $24,019 | $562,430 |
| Amanda Secor | CHIEF OF STAFF | Officer | 40 | $399,685 | $0 | $109,279 | $508,964 |
| Mary Sullivan | SVP SPECIAL PROJECTS | Highly paid employee | 40 | $376,283 | $0 | $98,154 | $474,437 |
| Karrie Drobnick | CHIEF STRATEGY AND EXPERIENCE OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $392,619 | $0 | $43,515 | $436,134 |
| Kristy Hesse | CHIEF HR OFFICER | Officer | 40 | $390,385 | $0 | $41,209 | $431,594 |
| Mary Lornson | SVP LENDING | Highly paid employee | 40 | $350,436 | $0 | $66,408 | $416,844 |
| Jake Buman | FINANCIAL ADVISOR | Highly paid employee | 40 | $380,764 | $0 | $25,238 | $406,002 |
Sources
- IRS e-file return 202611359349311366 (Form 990, period ending 2025-12-31): readable copy at ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer
- IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search for EIN 39-6264347
- Organization website (as filed): www.communityfirstcu.org